Customer reviews

Customers are getting lost in the sauce.

Lost in the Sauce is rated 4.9 out of 5 across 149 customer reviews on Judge.me, with more on Google. Every written review is here, unfiltered and in the customer's own words, sorted most loved first.

Verified buyer

Very addictive, very delicious, nice and spicy. Great quality sambal

N L. · Sep 2026 Reviewed on Amma's Malaysian Sambal
Verified buyer

The best hot sauce with the perfect combination of spicy and sweet (subtle). Can never have enough on hand because I go through it so quickly.

Nive · Aug 2026 Reviewed on Burning Mango
Verified buyer

Really good sauces. Very flavourful and perfect amount of heat for us.

Anonymous · Aug 2026 Reviewed on LITS Flavour Flight Sampler Set

great taste, great amount of 🌶️! love it!!

kate &.n. · Aug 2026 Reviewed on Burning Mango

Project Casper Sauce

As someone who loves both wings and hot sauce, this one was a fun surprise. It’s got a nice kick from the ghost peppers, but the peaches and maple syrup add just enough sweetness to balance it out. It’s not just spicy it actually has flavor, I’ve been using it on wings, but honestly it would be delicious on pretty much anything. Definitely one I’d keep stocked if you like a sweet + spicy combo. - Product gifted by Lost In The Sauce.

Kayla · Apr 2026 Reviewed on Project Casper
Verified buyer

We love the Project Casper hot sauce! It has a great sweet peach taste while packing a pleasant punch. It's wonderful in a sandwich, as a dip, on tacos, with fish and grilled meats. We order multiple bottles at once to make sure we never run out!

Audrey S. · Apr 2026 Reviewed on Project Casper

The flavor profile opens with subtle sweetness, transitions into a vibrant acidity, and concludes with a mild, warming pepper finish. It offers a refined, highly elevated interpretation of a classic sweet chili sauce.

Lisha K. · Aug 2026 Reviewed on Bodhi

Bodhi Sauce

I tried the Bodhi sauce and wow this one surprised me, It starts sweet, turns tangy, and that perfect little spicy kick at the end without being overpowering. We tried it with omelette first and instantly got hooked! It also tastes amazing with fish fillets, burgers, paneer, and honestly anything that needs extra flavour. I love that it tastes unique and homemade instead of just hot. Even better knowing it’s a Canadian, Toronto-based brand made with all natural ingredients. - Product gifted by Lost In The Sauce.

Pawanpreet · May 2026 Reviewed on Bodhi

Bodhi Sauce

I really enjoyed this hot sauce! At first I was super nervous as it's got a 4/5 heat rating, and though I like spicy foods, I'm not a pro. The sauce has a watery consistency which was surprising to me and made it too easy to over pour into a sauce plate or even into a marinade so be careful. By itself, it had a lovely sweetness and flavour to it, but it really packed on some heat. When I dipped it into foods, it paired wonderfully and the heat was a lot easier to handle. I really really enjoyed it and have been using it in all kinds of foods lately! - Product gifted by Lost In The Sauce.

Priscilla · Apr 2026 Reviewed on Bodhi

Amazing sauce!! Pairs well with literally everything!

kate &.n. · Aug 2026 Reviewed on Amma's Malaysian Sambal

About these reviews

Are these real customer reviews?

Yes. Every review on this page is collected and hosted by Judge.me, an independent review platform, and shown here unedited. Verified buyer badges mark reviews tied to a confirmed order. Where a product was sent to a reviewer at no charge, the review says so.

How do I leave a review?

Tap Write a review, pick the sauce you tried, and the review form opens. It takes about a minute. If you have ordered from us, you will also get a review invitation by email a couple of weeks after delivery.

Which sauce should I start with?

Most first-timers start with Burning Mango (sweet mango, medium heat) or OG Boodoo (our original Trinidadian-style pepper sauce). If you cook a lot, Amma's Malaysian Sambal works as a marinade, stir-fry base and dip. The Starter Pack gives you three to compare and saves 10%.

Find your flavour

Mix & match any 3 and save 10%. Any 6 is the full stack: 15% off plus a free mini. Free shipping on $50+.
View the full sauce menu →
Amma's Malaysian Sambal chili paste jar, a Lost in the Sauce x Bungkus collaboration
Amma's Malaysian Sambal
Heat 7/10 · $13.99
View
OG Boodoo Trinidadian pepper sauce bottle by Lost in the Sauce, white background
OG Boodoo
Heat 7/10 · $12.99
View
Bodhi ghost pepper and maple hot sauce bottle, a Lost in the Sauce x SPICYWTR collaboration
Bodhi
Heat 6.5/10 · $12.99
View
Burning Mango mango habanero hot sauce bottle by Lost in the Sauce, white background
Burning Mango
Heat 6/10 · $12.99
View
Project Casper peach maple ghost pepper hot sauce bottle by Lost in the Sauce, white background
Project Casper
Heat 6/10 · $12.99
View
Lime Chili mild salsa verde-style hot sauce bottle by Lost in the Sauce, white background
Lime Chili
Heat 3/10 · $12.99
View